https://amigastore.eu/en/994-mechanical-keyboard-amiga-1200.html
Interesting news this week - AMIGAstore.eu just released their own take
on a replacement *mechanical* keyboard for the A1200 form factor (which I'd guess could be adapted to the A500 as well with a little effort.)
This is notable for a couple of reasons:
https://amigastore.eu/en/994-mechanical-keyboard-amiga-1200.html
I've got one of the aeberbach/amibay setups, though, and love it. You'll have to pry it from my cold dead hands.
The AMIGAstore.eu keyboard has a couple of problems based on a thread on EAB that I read. First off is the keyboard/ctrl key issue. The Amiga keyboard had an oddly shaped spacebar. Getting one available today that
is the same dimensions is not currently possible without incurring additional cost, but I read that AMIGAstore.eu is possibly going to address this.
The second is that there doesn't appear to be a provision for a light at es> the caps lock key.
The third is that the keys appear to sit way too low in the A1200 es> chassis.
I've stumbled across these.
Still crazy in Canadian dollars. 270.90 CAD ! That doesn't include any shipping costs.
Man, I'd love to build a modern PC into a Amiga, but don't want to shell out $500 plus dollars for a case and keyboard.... ugh!
Ha! Nice. I knew you had one of these but couldn't remember if you had
the Aeberbach or the Kipper2k one.
My issue with that one, besides the price, was the supportability - the fact that these are being put out in tiny quantities by a single dude. Then again, one positive to most of these modern replacement mechanical keyboards is that they're based on common parts so self-repair should be possible in many cases, so maybe that's just me over thinking it. Still, for such an expensive purchase, I'd prefer having some kind of company standing behind their product. That said, I don't know that
AMIGAstore.eu is *that* company - they're not exactly huge, and while
I've ordered from them a ton in the past and never had any real issues, I've not had to deal with their support.
Ooooh, I need to find that EAB thread. I looked for one as I knew there would likely be one, but didn't find it via Google. I'll go check it out.
I'm not arguing here, but genuinely asking since you know a lot more
about Amigas and the modern Amiga scene scene than I do. Are you saying the AMIGAstore.eu keyboard has original key sizes, and *that* is a problem, or that it doesn't, and *that* is a problem? :P
Sergiusz' original design had the modern key cap sizes, so I'm assuming that the AMIGAstore.eu one does too. The KA 59 does too. I'm reading
that the Kipper2K, the Aeberbach, and of course the new A1200.net ones have the original key sizes.
It seems that on replacement keyboards with have non-original key sizes, the alt, ctrl, and space bar key cap length was done *intentionally* so that you could source your own and/or replacement caps much more easily. On the surface, that seems like a very good thing to me. A small trade
off unless you grew up with an Amiga 1200 and have the *precise* layout
of the keyboard burned into your brain. Not an issue for me. Am I
missing something else?
I suppose its not a keyboard for absolute purists, but then again,
having a mechanical keyboard in an A1200 isn't either. :P Plus, I'd
guess most of these people are using modern accelerators and modern versions of AmigaOS too. :P
Seriously though, throw that on the pile of concessions to modern convenience my Amiga 1200 already has - a SUPER white case care of a1200.net plus a reproduction case badge, both of which look genuine at
a glance but not so much when scrutinized. An accelerator that *did not exist* in the 90s (Terrible Fire) and a 68060 that would have been sheer unobtainium for me back then. A GoTEK and CF based hard drive, both of which would have blown our fucking minds back then, etc. etc. :D
A bigger issue re: key caps and one I'm frankly surprised AMIGAstore.eu didn't figure out before hand, is that it only includes the US key caps, and even in America most of us are going to be using UK Amigas. WTF were they thinking not launching with optional and/or add-on keycap sets for European countries? LOL! (They do say they're likely going to fix this
if sales are strong enough to warrant it, however.)
Yeah, this one is a bit of a bummer. It does have an LED under (but not inside of) the caps lock key as well as separate pads to run your own
caps lock LED so at least it's not like it has zero solution for this -
I think I read the Kipper2k one will flash your power LED or something silly like that, which seems a lot worse. I'd also suspect someone could come up with a clever way to use that onboard LED to shine through a key cap with a window in it, but then again, I have no idea how to source
such a specialized key cap either. *shrug* Does yours have a keycap with
a window in it?
Oh, interesting. I wondered about this from pictures I'd seen - it looks like the keys themselves are lower profile than the originals. That's... possibly a non-issue for me assuming its not so low to cause problems.
The Hi-tek A500 keys are similar in that they're not quite as tall but it's not an issue in terms of usability in the slightest. Again, it
might drive OG Amiga fans a purists insane though.
Honestly, none of these are deal breakers in my opinion. What do you think? Would you buy one assuming you didn't already have your fancy Aeberbach one? :P
Interesting news this week - AMIGAstore.eu just released their own take on a replacement *mechanical* keyboard for the A1200 form factor (which I'd guess could be adapted to the A500 as well with a little effort.)
I actually had a Kipper2k one! I won it off eBay and it arrived covered
in crystallized dried cat piss. I couldn't remove it. I got into an argument with the seller and he finally begrudgingly accepted the
return. International shipping both ways...ugh.
But it was a nice feeling keyboard for sure. I'll go out on a limb and
say the aeberbach one feels higher quality though...but I never
installed the kipper2k one.
I think with Amiga gear you're barking up the wrong tree. With rare exceptions, most things you'll find are hobbyist level things with
minimal support. Even if you find things that have some degree of actual supportability, there are other challenges. Like, AmigaKit never answers emails. Jens Schoenfeld's website sucks and the forum is a slow pain in the ass, and actually buying things on there now is crazy. Other vendors seem to be hit or miss depending on the day or phase of the moon, who knows.
Good luck as EAB has been suffering the AI LLM training crawler's collective hug of death. More than 20k guest accounts online at the same time DOSing the server :(
I don't think so, I think you're right on. Like, it wouldn't bother me, but some people are more purist about stuff. I have aftermarket
everything to include the mobo and case so wtf do I care lol.
Isn't it crazy we're trying to change a vintage keyboard into a different flavor of vintage keyboard? :P
Don't get me started on the PiStorm! There's now a 3d API project to hopefully be Warp3d compatible using PiStorm hardware. That will be amazing. What a fun time to be in the scene....
Yeah, it's a bummer, even the soft glow under the caps lock key without the window looks kinda trash to me. Mine does have a window, yes.
People in the Amiga world have been complaining about this yet nobody has actually bought and used one of these yet so it's all speculative. Gotta love the Amiga community!
Sure would! Feels like a no brainer to me. I'd snatch one up before they're gone and unobtanium, like tends to be the trend.
So yeah get one of 'em and lemme know what you think hehe.
Very awesome, I have a 500 myself, and a working keyboard, but the custom keycaps and backing plate offerred here is a huge deal, this is actually
a very reasonable price ($~250 USD). It's very hard to get replacement keyboards for retrocomputers, even with DIY with PCB and cherry mx switches because of the custom keycap sizes and prints are very
expensive to do and have to be done in large quantity.
Ahh I see from https://amigakb.wordpress.com/how-to-install/ that you
are meant to re-use your original backing plate, anyway that's a great design, the photos look really good, a perfect and flush finish. I have
an Atari 1200XL which would look pretty good if it weren't for the
angled space-age keys at the top all being slightly misaligned from one another.
I've got rough plans to do this myself and I think I have most if not
all of the parts assembled, but this one is very low on my priority list and I keep changing gears on what I want to use as the actual PC. A Pi would be the easiest, I think, but I was toying with chucking my old
MIST FPGA in there, but there are some other challenges there.
Oh fuck, I forgot about that - I remember you telling me about that now. Man, that sucked. :/ The thing I like most about the Kipper2k one is
that it has a lot of built in options to use it for more than a straight 1:1 Amiga keyboard replacement. For instance, IIRC it has a USB
controller so you could use it in a Pi or FPGA build, and if it was available at a decent price, it would be great for one of those sleeper style builds.
That all very well might be true, but I guess I personally expect more
out of a $160-$260 keyboard. :P
Ugh, I noticed. I went to go find that thread as soon as I left here and the board was completely down.
The layout is a bit different than I originally imagined in that the
space bar of the original keyboard is waaaaaaaaaaaaaay longer. Again, wouldn't bother me, but I could see some OG Amigaheads having legitimate concerns there. I do like that they added another ctrl key, though I'm
not sure if its position is that much more of an improvement to me. :P
I think its weirder that the new key caps are XDA. Just looks odd on a vintage computer keyboard, but that's an extremely minor gripe and being able to easily source your own is a nice enough trade-off.
Right?! My eyes just about roll back into my head completely when reading comments and discussions about this shit. You'll always have various people that are absolutely against it for some petty reason like "That shade of beige isn't quite the same as the original one... HARD PASS!" :D
Oh man, I forgot all about the PiStorm... :D All of the Pi stuff is also similarly mind blowing. Imagine trying to explain that some kids in the 90s? "No, look bro, we have a tiny computer that is in itself hundreds
or thousands of times faster than your actual computer shoved onto its motherboard JUST emulating the processor!"
I'll have to see it in person, I think, but I'm sure I'd prefer the
little window. Still, despite caps lock being cruise control for cool,
I'm not that cool, so I rarely use it. ;)
As usual. A shit ton of speculative shit talk with no real data. Ha!
There is actually an old video from Jan Beta where he installs one of
the original Sergiusz versions though it's not really an in-depth review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAo65CjaCHM
Okay, fine. Ordered! One of the positives of this being done by AMIGAshop.eu is that perhaps it won't be disappearing any time soon though. I'm also still very curious to see what a1200.net does - if they can come out with something that is completely compatible with the original keyboard including using the same keycaps, and do so at a
decent price, it could be compelling to a lot of retro Amiga fans who don't spend all of their time on EAB and AmiBay. :P
Yeah, I do think that this is true.
I'll go ahead and mention though that I had a black A1200.net Amiga
wedge case and though I never plugged the keyboard into the case, the keycaps and case colors were enough of a mismatch to make me think it would look a bit odd.
Then again I believe these computers should be function over form lol.
So says the guy with a huge gaming library that he's played less than 1% of.
Fair! I just think if this was easy/cheap it'd be ubiquitous. There's gotta be reasons why these haven't been done yet in mass quantities.
100%! It wouldn't bother me at all! But I was reading the EAB thread and one guy basically said he'd never be able to adjust to a different keyboard layout in his A1200. His loss.
Considering I have no idea what XDA is, I'll just google it and move on hehe.
Nostalgia is a powerful thing!
Y'know, my wife and I were talking about nostalgia a few days ago. I'm curious, does it have a biological/evolutionary advantage? In other
words, why are we so motivated by nostalgia? Does it positively impact
our survival?
Right?! It's crazy. A Pi 5 would have been a supercomputer to us back in the day, too. I love the creative renaissance this has created.
Haha. I don't think I've ever intentionally used caps lock :P So maybe
my gripe about the damn light window is just me being curmudgeonly.
Nice! Let me know what you think! I'd love to do a side by side
comparison with the aeberbach keyboard. Man, if I can convince myself to order an AMIGAStore one, I could...meh, not worth it. Hehe.
As for a1200.net, yeah, I'd be curious as well.
As usual. A shit ton of speculative shit talk with no real data. Ha!
There is actually an old video from Jan Beta where he installs one of
the original Sergiusz versions though it's not really an in-depth review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAo65CjaCHM